Lady
Hoopsters: A History of Women's Basketball in America
|
Chapter Eight: |
"Red Heads You
Kill Me" -
|
[The Red Heads] were just super, everyday people who just loved playing basketball. We played in little towns, for PTAs, churches, Kiwanis clubs. We played mens college teams, former NBA fellows . . . a lot of mens baseball and football players.
- Coach Orwell Moore of the Red Heads, 1997
Not much could be further from basketball
play days than the professional All-American Worlds
Champion Basketball Red Heads. And not much was more
glaringly obvious than the ambivalent emotions generated
by those who watched professional women basketball
players take on mens teams and beat them. What
could be further apart from what the physical education
establishment wanted for women? Not only was this
competitive basketball, but here were women playing men
by mens rulesfull courtto large crowds,
for money. Of course there was a catch. According to the
Babe Didrikson biography Whatta Gal, in
the 1930s "women and athletics" didnt
mix, so the only way for women athletes to make money was
as "sideshow exhibitionists." At least
thats what Babe Didrikson ended up doing. If women
were willing to play in a "vaudeville"-like
atmosphere and put on a "show," then that would
make it more palatable and people would pay money to see
it. Coach Orwell Moore of the All-American Red Heads told
me that for women to succeed professionally they must
"play good basketball and put on a show (but
"not a sideshow"). Thats what you
need." Just like the AAU tournaments and their
beauty contests, would-be female professional basketball
players would probably be expected to play in short
shorts. They would have to put up with articles in Colliers
calling their athletic efforts "sex appeal dished
out" in front of local crowds. But whatever the
press might say, the women players on the touring teams
between 1933 and 1970 were able to earn their money
playing the game they loved. Both of the first great
touring basketball teams were called All Americans: one
was the short-lived Babe Didrikson co-ed team, begun in
1933; and the other was the very long-lasting,
all-female, All-American Worlds Champion Red Heads,
founded in 1936.
Babe started playing for her touring team
immediately after leaving the Dallas Cyclones and amateur
sports. After her disagreement with the Cyclones about
her salary, she entered into even deeper controversy with
the AAU and Olympic officials. With all her success, her
female hormone levels became suspect, so she took to
wearing lace. Apparently that still wasnt enough
for the AAUs Avery Brundage who was moved to praise
the ancient Greeks who "kept women out of their
athletic games." Tired of the conflict, early in
1933 Babe Didrikson spoke about getting together a
womens pro basketball team. It was Roy Doan, a
promoter from Muscatine, Iowa, who actually arranged for
the "Babes All-Americans" tour. He knew
people would flock to see her, maybe as a great woman
athlete, but also probably as a sort of sideshow freak.
The same thing happened to legendary black Olympian Jesse
Owens in 1937, when the only way he could make enough
money to go to college was to agree to a promoters
scheme for him to run races against thoroughbred horses.
Even as an amateur, Babe Didrikson had
always insisted on being shown the money. Why
shouldnt a female athlete earn money doing what she
did best? As the star attraction of Babes
All-Americans, Babe pulled down $1,000 a month, a lot
in U.S. Depression dollars. It was her name that
drew in the people, and they came in droves. The
team was organized by Doan in the fall of 1933. He
planned for four men and two to three women to barnstorm
through country towns, playing mens teams. One of
the women on the team was Jackie Mitchell, the Texas AAU
basketball and baseball star. People were struggling with
tough times, but they really enjoyed the distraction of
Babes team coming to town.
For a five-month season in 1933-34,
Babes All-Americans played 91 games across seven
states, grabbing headlines everywhere. They rolled
through Iowa, South Dakota, Missouri, Illinois,
Massachusetts, New Jersey, and New York. The Springfield
Hall of Fame has a great February 12, 1934 poster
advertising Babes team coming to Saratoga Springs,
New York, to take on the "Paramount 5." They
beat three quarters of the teams they faced. Babes
All-Americans toured in a seven-passenger sedan with a
luggage trailer. In contrast to her past experience, Babe
was well-liked by her touring teammates, who, according
to team member Dick Butzen, appreciated her humor and
generosity. Her generosity still extended to her family
also, whom she regularly sent hundreds of dollars in cash
through the mail.
Babe also got along well with the short,
blond and "feminine" Virne "Jackie"
Mitchell. According to a 1933 St. Louis Dispatch
article, neither woman "had an interest in men from
a standpoint of other than athletics." That was
apparently a 1930s way to suspect not only the normalcy
of Babes hormone levels, but to question her sexual
preferences. Such questions would become more commonplace
and more open for any successful female athlete as the
century wore on. Didrikson biographer Susan Cayleff notes
that "groups of women playing passionately and
intimately together," in games of
"unwomanly" physical contact could count on
being suspected of lesbianism. Babe wore lace and married
George Zaharias to try to counter societys
perception of her "mannishness." But being on a
touring co-ed basketball team which regularly beat
mens teams probably didnt add to an image of
femininity. Nor did it help when she followed the
basketball tour with a tour on the male House of David
baseball team. Babe always fought for the right of woman
athletes to pursue their sport professionally and with
dignity. Babe Didrikson died of cancer in 1956 after a
brilliant track and field, baseball, billiards, golf, and
basketball career.
Didrikson had often been treated like a
phenomenon, like a woman far from the normal female
athlete. She no doubt got very tired of fighting for a
woman athletes right to be taken seriously, and not
as a freak show. When I had the chance to speak to the
now 81-year-old Coach Orwell Moore and his wife Lorene
Moore of the Red Heads, one of the questions I really
wanted to have them answer for me was: Did the Red Heads
just put on "a show" against the mens
teams they played, or was it serious basketball? Their
answers were not as uncomplicated as I had anticipated.
In February of 1947, John K. Lageman wrote a piece on the Red Heads for Colliers called "Red Heads You Kill Me." The accompanying photos show players garbed in short shorts, and some show opposing male players reaching to grab them inappropriately. One picture is captioned: "Ouch my manicure! exclaimed pretty Ruth Haines, nursing her fingernail, as Mary McGee saves the ball. The girls use perfume on and off the court." [!] Meanwhile "the girls" look very athletic, and more concerned about rebounds than manicures. Lageman uses a cutesy, sexy tone throughout the article, no doubt making the subject of women playing mens teams much more palatable to his readership. The public had been seeing all-womens basketball teams on tour before: the Edmonton Grads, the AAUs Hanes team, and the African-American Philadelphia Hustle squad, had all travelled the country. In 1949 AAU All-American Hazel Walker organized a womens pro touring team called the Arkansas Travelers. Lurlyne Greer Mealhouse of the Hanes team played for the Travelers in the 1950s. The team toured the country until 1966. But by far the longest-lived womens touring pro basketball organization was the All-American Red Heads, which sent out touring teams between 1936 and 1986.
Coach Orwell Moore assured me that "the
Red Heads were the best womens team in the 20th
century." Moore says "those women could really
play. . . could really shoot. There has never been anyone
like them." They were successful because they were
"very competitive" ballplayers, but they could
also "put on a show."
In 1936 C.M. Ole Olson of Crossville,
Missouri, sent out the first Red Head squad. They were
originally called the "All-American Worlds
Championship Girls Basketball Club," but soon
became simply the All-American Red Heads. Olsons
wife ran some beauty salons, and player Peggy Lawson had
the idea that the team could advertise the salons by
wearing Mrs. Olsons "dos" and
dyeing theirs a distinctive red. Lawson thought the
teams hair color should match that of their
red-haired players, the Langerman twins (Jo and Genevra)
and then they could call the team the Red Heads. So the
women dyed their hair red, but they never wore red
wigs, according to former player Lorene Moore, who was
indignant at the thought. Eventually the fans came to
expect (and demand) red heads when they came to see the
team. The original Red Heads included great players like
Peggy Lawson Surface, Hazel Vickers Cone, Lera Dunford,
Ruth Osborn, Kay Kirkpatrick Phillips (who joined a bit
later), and the phenomenal redheaded Iowa twins, Jo and
Genevra Langerman. Olson managed the team, who played
male teams using five-player, mens rules. At one
point, Olson featured the attraction of track star Helen
Stevens running races against men at halftime. From the
start, fans flocked to see them. Their won-lost record is
quoted as about 50% for the 1930s and 40s. Scheduling 185
games in six months, they played through 30 states, and
in the Philippines and Hawaii.
The Red Heads style was to liberally
use "fancy play": gags, "trick
shots," and dribbling with their knees. The
players "laugh-provoking antics"
entertained the millions who eventually would see them.
Coach Moore says he had some amazing dribblers. It made
for some great halftime shows. One player could dribble
two balls at once blindfolded. Shed go down on the
floor and back up again, keeping them going. Some of
these entertaining Red Heads received offers from
Hollywood, but none of them went. A 1976 Red Heads
promotional flyer echoes Coach Moores secret to
their longtime success: "skilled basketball
wizardry" good players and tricks.
The Red Heads had seen steady success into
the 1940s, but owner Ollie Olson did call a two-year halt
during the war years, believing that in wartime a
"womans place was at the lathe." By the
late 40s, they were more than back in business, beating
any womens team they faced, and at least half of
the local mens teams who met them in their highly
popular contests. In 1947, Lageman said they travelled
30,000 miles in a year in a station wagon they called
"The Nellie J. Bly," playing 180 games in 38
states.
As noted, Lagemans account of Red Head
play is mocking and sarcastic. He describes the players
as wearing "sassy red slacks," and reminds the
readers (and himself?): "But its basketball-
not a strip tease!" Lageman said that during the
game he observed, the local mens team discussed
strategy, while Red Head coach Joe Turner talked to his
team about watching out for the opponents wives
and girlfriends, so they could use the information and
distract the men during the game. On the one hand,
Lageman noted that Red Head Captain Lorene Daniels was a
great player. She led her high school in Byng, Oklahoma
to 100 straight victories and three state championships.
But he also claims that in this game, Daniels and team
use their "female guile" to bother some of the
newly-married males on the opposing side and then score
on them. He notes that Red Head "Walker" was a
national free throw champ, and shes
"not bad to look at."
As basketball players, Lageman calls the Red
Heads "fast and tricky." But, he went on, as
the "women themselves admitted," they would
have no chance against the average man, unless they could
"bedizen" and "ensnare" him. He calls
guard Mary Alice "Peachie" Hatcher a
"clinging vine," and describes how Mary McGee
got the men to put an arm around her so the ref would
call a foul. Then he tells us about one of the Red
Heads trick shots which featured the 52"
Allegra "Stubby" Winter riding piggyback on
Ruth Haines for a basket. For Lageman, the whole game was
"sex appeal dished out" in front of a local
crowd.
Its hard to say how these excellent
women basketball players might have done in a straight
game against those men on that particular night, given
that the game in those days was not the power-dunk game
it is now. Coach Moore coached both Daniels and Haines,
and he told me he spoke to Haines about this particular
game. She remembers both teams and the ref
clowning in red wigs. (So theres at least one time
with wigs.) Moore said the coaches did get information on
the men "to use for the show. . . . The women played
seriously, but with a smile. . . They wanted to create
the thought the women could beat them at any time.
The women always wanted to win. Never forget that."
Its obvious that Lageman and the American public
were still somewhat ambivalent watching lady athletes who
wanted to win.
It was 1955 when Coach Orwell Moore and his
wife Lorene Moore bought the Red Heads from Olson, moving
the headquarters to Caraway, Arkansas. The team had
remained steadily successful, bagging 134 wins in 1953,
all against mens teams. Coach Moore had been a high
school coach before coming to the Red Heads to coach
their western unit in 1948. Lorene "Butch"
Moore was the Red Heads all-time scoring leader
with more than 35,000 points in her 12-year career,
billed on their 1976 flyer as "the greatest
individual scorer in the history of girls
basketball." She also is a very modest, retiring
woman. When asked what her secret was for scoring so many
points, she said: "Theres no secret. I just
played hard. We all played hard."
Lorene Adams Moore says she started playing
basketball in grade school, in the hills of Caraway,
Arkansas. She played all through school; she was always
playing. She married Orwell Moore right out of high
school. She went on to play for Arkansas State (now
Arkansas State University). When Moore graduated from
Arkansas State in the late 40s, she joined the Red Heads,
playing for her coach/husband. She describes playing for
six months of the year, every night: "We played all
the time and played real hard. And yes, I enjoyed it! . .
. We played all over the country, even in Alaska. . . .
played all over the world." As far as the red wigs
that so many stories on them insist they wore, she says
they didnt: "Can you see a man wearing
a wig? . . . We did dye our hair though." Wigs would
have been over the top.
When I asked Lorene Moore my burning question about whether or not the Red Heads played serious basketball as opposed to what Lageman described in Colliers in 1947, she said it had definitely been serious basketball. They "played for real." She said that shes read those magazine articles, too, and sometimes "they twisted things." [Me: "Probably written by men." Moore: "Yes, thats it!"] When I said some writers implied they were all show like the Globetrotters, she said it was all serious play. Her husband the coach does stress the "show" aspect more.
Lorene Moore explained that from the
beginning the Red Heads always played mens rules
basketball. They always played full court, continuous
dribble. She says the Red Heads never played womens
teams: "They wouldnt have been any
competition." So they only played mens teams.
That was their "drawing card" men
playing against women. "Nowadays its
commonplace. Happens all the time." The Red Heads
played men, and they won by a large percentage, she
didnt remember the number. When asked about the
mens reactions to being beaten, she was quick to
reply: "How would they react? A man getting
beaten by a woman?! Most of them were very nice. . . But
when you stole the ball- ! [She laughed]." Coach
Moore says that Lorene was good at that, and a lot more:
"She was the greatest faker youve ever seen.
She had that extra something." She could play any
position and was always their highest scorer. She could
take foul shots off her knee and did, in
games. Moore told me she always "played hard. Played
until I couldnt play any more [because of
age]." Lorene Moore simply loved playing basketball.
Unlike Mrs. Moore, Coach Moore could not be
described as retiring, but more like a ringmaster. He
said that as soon as his Red Head players came on the
court, people knew they were "super, everyday people
who just loved playing basketball." For Red Heads,
"basketball had to be first." Supportive
families kept track of their players with pins on a map.
After the hometown girl got famous playing with the Red
Heads, she might land a great job or marry "the best
guy in town. . . . If they got through that, they stayed
with the Red Heads." They played "a serious
game," but " they also put on a
show." Coach Moore explained all those magazine
articles by saying that the reporters were picking up on
"the show." When Moore took over the Red Heads
he had some great ballplayers, making up "the best
womens team in the 20th century. There were none
better. No-o!"
When asked to contrast the
"non-serious," limited, offensive/defensive
womens game played by the schools and sometimes the
AAU in the 1940s and 50s, with the more
"serious" play of the Red Heads, Coach Moore
disagreed with the distinction. He explained that even
with three dribbles, playing on half the court, it was
still serious play"just different rules."
He told me that when he coached high school ball,
theyd get a "great big girl" for center.
And then theyd have a real advantage, especially
with the limits the rules placed on guards playing
someone with the ball. Moore said that he had no trouble
getting new players for the Red Head brand of basketball.
By the late 40s, with the Red Heads fame, woman
players came to them. (In fact, he says they still inquired
in 1997, after the Red Heads had been disbanded for over
10 years!) The coach did use to look for new talent at
the high school and AAU tournaments, although high school
tournaments were few and far between in those days. He
got a lot of good players from Oklahoma, and especially
from Mississippi. By then, there was no friendly trading
of players with the "amateur" AAU though. Coach
Olson had picked up many former AAU All-Americans when
their AAU teams faded. Moore said that the Red Heads and
the AAU became "enemies" because the AAU was
jealous of them. So his players didnt go to the
Olympics; there was no interchange between groups:
"No-o!"
I was also still curious about how the Red
Heads played and beat mens teams (a feat my husband
assures me is impossible). Coach Moore told me the way to
do it was to control the game. The women had to be
"excellent at blocking out." He said that
theres too many out-of-bounds plays now. His girls
knew to put the ball in the basket when they had it. They
were also "better shooters than you have nowadays.
We had to play our game." They had to control the
game. If they went up against a fast team, since there
was no play clock, the women could keep the ball
indefinitely, control the pace and the game.
In the 1940s and 50s, the Red Heads also
took advantage of the (mens) rule that said after a
foul, the team fouled could take one foul shot and then
take it out of bounds. The women had a much-used play
where theyd take it out after a made free throw,
whip it in, and run a screen for a player to make a set
shot and get three points out of the trip. Moore also
noted to me that the officials also had to be in
control, to make sure the men played and
didnt "just mess around," and to prevent
any possible spiteful violence from the men players
towards the Red Heads. "Of course," Moore went
on, "the style of play [for women and men]
was different then." There were lots of set shots
and drives. I asked about dunks and he said
nonobody dunked then, not the men either. He had
girls who could jump up and grab the rim. They could have
dunked if they wanted to. Anyway, it was against the
rules. And, he added, "how we could have used the
three-point shot!" He would have loved that.
The pride in his team very evident, Coach
Moore at one point asked me what I thought of the
Red Heads. I expressed my genuine enthusiasm about their
skills and excellence as ballplayers. I only wish I could
have seen them play. My favorite Red Head story from
Coach Moore was the one he told about one contest held
against a mens team at a local high school. They
had requested no "show," ("No-o!")
but straight basketball. So by the third quarter, the Red
Heads were leading the men by 16. "Then,
Moore says, they wanted a show."
The professional Red Heads womens
basketball team would still be going strong in the 1960s,
in fact until 1986. They would play to hundreds of
thousands, and log hundreds of thousands of miles on the
road. In a vehicle which was a later incarnation from
Nellie J. Bly, called "She Has To"( has to have
water, oil, gas, tires), the Red Heads might average
40,000 miles in six months. They made one-night stops,
sometimes covering 500 miles to get to a game scheduled
for the next day. They were written up in Sports Life,
Life Magazine, Sports Illustrated and Womens
Sports. They appeared on "Ive Got a
Secret," "Real People," and
"Whats My Line." Between 1964 and 1971,
the Red Heads sent out as many as three touring teams at
the same time. The first all womens professional
basketball team has also been the most successful.
The Red Heads played a full court/
mens rules, serious basketball game, but they also
were expected to interrupt the game to do the clever
tricks and put on the kind of "show" that made
women athletes easier for society to accept. In a similar
way, perhaps the showmanship of the Harlem Globetrotters
made black athleticism more palatable to whites. Still,
the Red Heads were the first women besides Babe to be
truly professional basketball players. They got to do
what they loved most and were paid too. It would be a
long time before women successfully established a
womens professional basketball league. And when
they did, they still had promoters who wanted them to
play against Playboy Bunnies.